Lynch Solicitors - Personal Injuries & Equity Litigation, Medical Negligence, Bankruptcy,  Property and Estates  & Divorce and Family Law

Call Us: +353 52 6124344 | Email: [email protected]
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury & Litigation
      • DePuy Hip Implant
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • Accidents at Work
      • Acident on Roads & Footpaths
      • Mental Illness & Claims
      • Repetitive Strain Injuries
      • Pessonal Injuries Board
      • Time Limits to Claim
    • Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Professional Negligence
      • Do I have a Case
      • Tips on Medical Negligence Cases
      • Medical Negligence – Narcolepsy
      • Time Limits to Claim
      • Solicitors in Medical Negligence
    • Divorce & Family Issues
      • Divorce
      • Breakdowns – the Options
      • How Assets are Dealt with
      • How Maintenance is assessed
      • Prenup & Co-habit Agreements
      • Mediation
      • Civil Partnerships
    • Property Services
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Rights Of Way Explained
      • How to own Property with another
      • Tips on Selling a Property
      • Tips on Business Leases
      • Tips on Renting
    • Wills, Succession & Estates
      • How a Will works
      • Why to make a Will
      • Executors, Guardians , Trustees & Attorneys
      • Enduring Powers of Attorney
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Bereavement - the Legal Process
      • Rights of Spouses and Children
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions
    • Our Fees
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookie Policy
CALL USSEND US YOUR QUERY
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Medical Negligence
  • DePuy Hip Recall Update
22/03/2023
John Lynch
Wednesday, 04 December 2013 / Published in Medical Negligence

DePuy Hip Recall Update

John M. Lynch on DePuy Hip Recall Update

[soundcloud id=’165871080′]

Download our 2013 in Review – DePuy Hip Recall Update notes Tipp FM

As John Lynch celebrates 30 years in business this year, this month we will review areas of law and cases that have been particularly topical in 2013.  John, last week you spoke on the show about cases you have worked on over the years that have opened the floodgates.  One example of this in recent years is the DePuy ASR hip implant recall.

Most listeners will be aware that we act for many clients who have suffered as a result of the worldwide recall by DePuy Orthopaedics Inc. on the 26th August 2010 of two of its hip replacement devices.

To recap, how many people in Ireland were fitted with the DePuy devices?

As matters stand, 3,282 patients in Ireland were fitted with the defective DePuy ASR hip implants.

It is estimated that nearly half of all DePuy ASR hip implants could fail within 6 years and require revision of the primary surgery.

Many of our clients have already undergone this revision procedure and experienced the difficulties of undergoing a second surgery.

We are more than surprised at the accelerating rate of revisions required since we started to work with people who have had DePuy implants.

As well as revision surgery DePuy patients will need annual blood checks for metal ions for the rest of their lives following an investigation by the British Medical Journal and BBC Newsnight in September 2012.  The report outlines that metal on metal hip implant patients will need annual blood tests due to the issue of metal particles dislodging from the implant.

Were the devices recalled in other countries before the Irish recall?

The problems with the two DePuy devices were known long before the recall.

In Australia, the National Joint Replacement Registry (NJRR) reported in 2007 that data for the previous year showed that these devices had twice the risk of failure in comparison to similar devices.

In 2008, the NJRR re-confirmed that these devices had a much higher than expected failure rate.  Again, in 2009, the NJRR found the same failure results.

In December 2009 DePuy Orthopaedics withdrew from the Australian market and in March 2010 DePuy issued an alert about the ASR implants.

Despite these developments many Irish patients continued to be implanted with the DePuy devices until the recall of the device in Ireland in August 2010.

What stage are the cases now at?

Many of our files against DePuy are now at an advanced stage.

In these cases the legal team for DePuy has reviewed the extensive medical records that we have supplied.

DePuy have admitted responsibility in some of the cases and have even asked us to meet with them to discuss settlement.

In these cases we are updating our medical reports so that we have a full picture of the current medical situation and can advise clients on the appropriate level of compensation.

Has the HSE reacted to the DePuy hip recalls?

Arising out the DePuy ASR debacle, the Heath Service Executive is to order a major review of all patients fitted with metal-on-metal artificial hips.

An estimated 6,500 of the devices have been fitted to Irish patients.  This figure includes the 3,500 DePuy ASR hip devices and a further 3,000 which were made by other manufacturers, many of which are still being used.  The move follows a similar investigation, which was launched by the UK’s medical devices regulatory agency, the MHRA, last year.

A new Irish national database of all knee and hip joint replacement surgeries is due to log its first patients.

Do databases exist in other countries where the DePuy devices were recalled?

Similar registries exist in the UK, Sweden, Australia and New Zealand and were credited with detecting issues with the DePuy ASR hip device prior to its recall. The plan is that the Register will not only monitor the performance of medical devices, but it will also monitor the activity of medical professionals who fit the devices as well as the institutions in which the hip replacement procedures are carried out.

It is our hope and aspiration that the work that we have done in the conduct of our cases for our clients has resulted in the changes that have been made to a system that was in serious need of an overhaul.

It should not have taken litigation to ensure that we had a Joint Register, an automatic retention of devices for forensic purposes, or a more thorough pre vetting of such devices before they are released onto the market.

We look forward, over the next number of months, to bringing any of the cases that we are involved in to a satisfactory finish for our clients.


For further advice or if you wish to discuss any other legal area please contact [email protected] or telephone 052-6124344.

The material contained in this blog is provided for general information purposes only and does not amount to legal or other professional advice. While every care has been taken in the preparation of the information, we advise you to seek specific advice from us about any legal decision or course of action.

Tagged under: DePuy Hips, Medical Negligence

4 Comments to “ DePuy Hip Recall Update”

  1. Jean Ann Dullea says :Reply
    01/01/2015 at 5:45 pm

    Had a hip resurface under NTPF late 2007. Have it checked now every year. Next check due March 2015. I’m worried about problems. Can I still make a claim for this unsuitable implant. I live in west cork.

    1. John M. Lynch says :Reply
      05/01/2015 at 9:27 am

      There is a time limit in these cases,as there is in all legal actions. However , the calculation of when time runs out is somewhat complicated where there are no symptoms or evidence of injury. Each case has to be looked at individually to see that it is still in time to take legal action.

  2. Jean Ann Dullea says :Reply
    15/01/2015 at 3:34 pm

    My DePuy ref. ASR-IRL-11191. Blood report Apr.2014 were Cobalt 122*nmo/L. Colbalt 7.20* ug/L (ppb). Chromium 92 nmo/L Chromium 4.78 ug/L (PPB). These have rises slightly each year. As said next review in March, no real discomfort at moment so grateful for your response please to whether I should have a claim. Regards Jean Dullea. Tel 023 8845561.

    1. John M. Lynch says :Reply
      20/01/2015 at 12:10 pm

      Indicators of the possibilities of a claim are usually increasing and high bloods , physical symptoms and evidence of damage or a combination of these.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pages

  • Blog
  • Blog Categories
  • Contact Us
  • Divorce
  • Divorce Google Form Contact Form
  • Home
  • Our Fees
  • Our Team
    • Catherine McGrath
    • Emma Greene
    • Gabriele Plek
    • Gillian O’ Mahony
    • John M. Lynch
    • Roisín Kelly
    • Susanna Manton
  • Practice Areas
    • Arbitration
    • Mediation
    • Medical Negligence
    • Other Areas
    • Personal Injury and Accident
      • Accidents at Work
      • DePuy ASR Hip Implant Recall
      • Medical Negligence – A Quick Guide
      • Occupational Asthma
      • Repetitive Strain Injury
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • The Injuries Board – PIAB Process
      • Time Limits
    • Property Services
      • Co-ownership Agreements
      • Commercial Tenancies
      • Private Residential Tenancies
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Transfer of Assets
    • Separation, Divorce & Relationship Issues
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Maintenance
      • Marriage Breakdowns – Your Options
      • Prenuptial and Cohabitation Agreements
    • Wills,Succession & Estates
      • Bereavement Legal Issues
      • Enduring Power of Attorney – Preparing for the Future
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Spouses and Children: Know Your Inheritance Rights
      • Wills
  • Publications
  • Videos

WHAT ARE WE ABOUT

We strive to give a voice to you as an Individual. We offer client focused service and cutting edge process and technology through ongoing research. We represent the Individual as opposed to the large Organisation. We look after you in your dealings with the Establishment or, what might be called , the Institutional forces in society.

CONTACT US

+353 (52) 6124344

Office Address: Jervis House, Parnell Street, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary, Ireland.
Email: [email protected]

GOT A QUESTION - CONTACT US
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2017 | All rights reserved | Lynch Solicitors

TOP });