Lynch Solicitors - Personal Injuries & Equity Litigation, Medical Negligence, Bankruptcy,  Property and Estates  & Divorce and Family Law

Call Us: +353 52 6124344 | Email: [email protected]
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury & Litigation
      • DePuy Hip Implant
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • Accidents at Work
      • Acident on Roads & Footpaths
      • Mental Illness & Claims
      • Repetitive Strain Injuries
      • Pessonal Injuries Board
      • Time Limits to Claim
    • Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Professional Negligence
      • Do I have a Case
      • Tips on Medical Negligence Cases
      • Medical Negligence – Narcolepsy
      • Time Limits to Claim
      • Solicitors in Medical Negligence
    • Divorce & Family Issues
      • Divorce
      • Breakdowns – the Options
      • How Assets are Dealt with
      • How Maintenance is assessed
      • Prenup & Co-habit Agreements
      • Mediation
      • Civil Partnerships
    • Property Services
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Rights Of Way Explained
      • How to own Property with another
      • Tips on Selling a Property
      • Tips on Business Leases
      • Tips on Renting
    • Wills, Succession & Estates
      • How a Will works
      • Why to make a Will
      • Executors, Guardians , Trustees & Attorneys
      • Enduring Powers of Attorney
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Bereavement - the Legal Process
      • Rights of Spouses and Children
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions
    • Our Fees
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookie Policy
CALL USSEND US YOUR QUERY
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Medical Negligence
  • Symphysiotomy
24/03/2023
John Lynch
Saturday, 06 October 2012 / Published in Medical Negligence

Symphysiotomy

Tipp FM Legal Slot – 17th July 2012

 

Gillian O’Mahony on Symphysiotomy

[soundcloud id=’167071752′]

 

Download Symphysiotomy NotesTipp FM

What is Symphysiotomy?

Symphysiotomy was first advocated in 1597. Symphysiotomies became a routine surgical procedure for women experiencing an obstructed labour. They became less frequent in the late 19th century after the risk of maternal death.

A symphysiotomy is a barbaric procedure where the obstetrician breaks a woman’s pelvis, cutting it into two to facilitate the delivery of her baby.  This procedure was discontinued and replaced by a caesarean operation in the early part of the 20th century in the developed world, except in Ireland.

How many women had the symphysiotomy procedure in Ireland and when did the procedures take place?

1,500 Irish women were victims of symphysiotomy between 1944 and 1992.

Were the women aware that they were having a symphysiotomy, did they give their consent to the procedure?

These medical professionals abused their power by performing completely unnecessary and damaging procedures on women who were at their most vulnerable.  In many cases the procedures were concealed, the women were not given information before or after the surgery and their consent was not sought or given.  What is even more disturbing is that most of the women who underwent this procedure were not aware of it until several years later or until very recently. Last week a case came before our Supreme Court and the five-judge court said the procedure should never have been carried out on the lady in question particularly when she was unconscious and under anaesthetic.

Why is the area of symphysiotomy so topical at the moment?

Last week the Supreme Court upheld a High Court decision that a symphysiotomy carried out on an 18 year old in 1969 at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda was “entirely unjustified and unwarranted”.  The woman in this case did not know that she had a symphysiotomy until almost 33 years later when she heard a radio programme about it.  She suffered chronic on-going pain, continuous back pain, incontinence and depression as a result of the symphysiotomy. The Supreme Court awarded compensation in the sum of €325,000.

Why did the procedures take place?

It has been suggested that the laws of the Catholic Church influenced the use of symphysiotomies in Ireland long after they were discontinued elsewhere. Symphysiotomy appears to have been heavily influenced by Catholic teaching forbidding contraception.  It has also been claimed that many of the operations in Ireland after 1940 were carried out – without prior knowledge or consent – “mainly for religious reasons, by obstetricians who were opposed to family planning”.

The Organisation for Survivors of Symphysiotomy has claimed that obstetricians chose to perform a symphysiotomy instead of the far safer caesarean operation because the doctors viewed caesareans as a method of birth control because women can have no more than around four caesareans.  For a doctor to carry out a Caesarean section on a woman was to limit the size of her family.  Once a Caesarean, always a Caesarean: this was the medical view which meant that Caesareans were
associated with family planning.

In the recent Supreme Court case did the Supreme Court make any particular comments about symphysiotomy?

It did indeed, in fact Mr Justice John MacMenamin said that the procedure “was wrong, even by the standards of the time” and there was “no rationale for it”, and that the “entire fault” for what happened to her lay with the obstetrician who carried out the procedure, , “and no one else”.

Were there long-term effects on the health of the women who had the symphysiotomy?

Women who have had a symphysiotomy suffered permanent damage as a result.  Many women have suffered a life of pain and discomfort because of incontinence, chronic pain, prolapsed organs, neurological and psychological problems.


For further advice or if you wish to discuss any other legal area please contact [email protected] or telephone 052-6124344.

The material contained in this blog is provided for general information purposes only and does not amount to legal or other professional advice. While every care has been taken in the preparation of the information, we advise you to seek specific advice from us about any legal decision or course of action.

Tagged under: Symphysiotomy

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pages

  • Blog
  • Blog Categories
  • Contact Us
  • Divorce
  • Divorce Google Form Contact Form
  • Home
  • Our Fees
  • Our Team
    • Catherine McGrath
    • Emma Greene
    • Gabriele Plek
    • Gillian O’ Mahony
    • John M. Lynch
    • Roisín Kelly
    • Susanna Manton
  • Practice Areas
    • Arbitration
    • Mediation
    • Medical Negligence
    • Other Areas
    • Personal Injury and Accident
      • Accidents at Work
      • DePuy ASR Hip Implant Recall
      • Medical Negligence – A Quick Guide
      • Occupational Asthma
      • Repetitive Strain Injury
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • The Injuries Board – PIAB Process
      • Time Limits
    • Property Services
      • Co-ownership Agreements
      • Commercial Tenancies
      • Private Residential Tenancies
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Transfer of Assets
    • Separation, Divorce & Relationship Issues
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Maintenance
      • Marriage Breakdowns – Your Options
      • Prenuptial and Cohabitation Agreements
    • Wills,Succession & Estates
      • Bereavement Legal Issues
      • Enduring Power of Attorney – Preparing for the Future
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Spouses and Children: Know Your Inheritance Rights
      • Wills
  • Publications
  • Videos

WHAT ARE WE ABOUT

We strive to give a voice to you as an Individual. We offer client focused service and cutting edge process and technology through ongoing research. We represent the Individual as opposed to the large Organisation. We look after you in your dealings with the Establishment or, what might be called , the Institutional forces in society.

CONTACT US

+353 (52) 6124344

Office Address: Jervis House, Parnell Street, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary, Ireland.
Email: [email protected]

GOT A QUESTION - CONTACT US
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2017 | All rights reserved | Lynch Solicitors

TOP });