Lynch Solicitors - Personal Injuries & Equity Litigation, Medical Negligence, Bankruptcy,  Property and Estates  & Divorce and Family Law

Call Us: +353 52 6124344 | Email: [email protected]
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury & Litigation
      • DePuy Hip Implant
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • Accidents at Work
      • Acident on Roads & Footpaths
      • Mental Illness & Claims
      • Repetitive Strain Injuries
      • Pessonal Injuries Board
      • Time Limits to Claim
    • Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Professional Negligence
      • Do I have a Case
      • Tips on Medical Negligence Cases
      • Medical Negligence – Narcolepsy
      • Time Limits to Claim
      • Solicitors in Medical Negligence
    • Divorce & Family Issues
      • Divorce
      • Breakdowns – the Options
      • How Assets are Dealt with
      • How Maintenance is assessed
      • Prenup & Co-habit Agreements
      • Mediation
      • Civil Partnerships
    • Property Services
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Rights Of Way Explained
      • How to own Property with another
      • Tips on Selling a Property
      • Tips on Business Leases
      • Tips on Renting
    • Wills, Succession & Estates
      • How a Will works
      • Why to make a Will
      • Executors, Guardians , Trustees & Attorneys
      • Enduring Powers of Attorney
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Bereavement - the Legal Process
      • Rights of Spouses and Children
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions
    • Our Fees
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookie Policy
CALL USSEND US YOUR QUERY
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Separation, Divorce & Relationship Issues
  • Second bite in Divorce after “full and final” separation agreement
24/03/2023
John Lynch
Tuesday, 22 November 2011 / Published in Separation, Divorce & Relationship Issues

Second bite in Divorce after “full and final” separation agreement

Marriage Breakdown

Today I will continue with my monthly legal news brief by discussing a recent landmark case involving proper provision in divorce where there is a prior separation agreement.

G. v G. involved a couple who married in 1977.  They lived in a house which the husband inherited from his aunt and uncle.  The wife had £3,000 savings when they married and they ran a garage and farm at the start of their marriage.  The husband pursued property development, building and selling houses developed by a company called C.P. Ltd.  They separated in 1995.  A separation agreement was entered into in 1996 and a “full and final settlement” clause was a feature of it.

Separation agreement

In 2002 the maintenance was increased.  The wife continued to live in the house and had spent the £70,000 lump sum without any investment.  She claimed she incurred debts until her maintenance was increased in 2007 and sought divorce.

Proper Provision

In 2009 the High Court granted a divorce.  The former husband was directed to provide extensive further provision including purchasing a €600,000 annuity, €300,000 for a pension fund, €100,000 to his former wife’s solicitors, maintenance of €54,000 to increase annually, part payment of the maintenance per month until the full maintenance is annuitized, €1,000,000 for the purchase of accommodation, VHI payment, insurance policy of €500,000, €600,000 for the former wife’s own use and benefit and to pay half the costs of the former wife in this case.

He appealed the High Court order.

Appeal to Supreme Court

The weight given to the separation agreement was firstly considered.  The husband submitted that he made proper and permanent provision which was intended to be in full and final settlement. Denham CJ set out general principles such as: for that, a separation agreement should be given sufficient weight; that a clean break is a legitimate expectation in Irish law; proper provision is not redistribution of wealth; if the circumstances of the spouses have changed significantly and this should be considered by the court.  Examples of a change in circumstances to be considered include an illness or a change in the value of assets.  If a spouse acquires wealth after separation and the wealth is unconnected to an investment/project during their marriage the other spouse is not automatically entitled to a share in the wealth or further money.  The length of time since the separation agreement will be considered.  The standard of living of the spouse seeking funds should be judged on the standard of living before they lived apart.  Inherited assets will not be treated as assets obtained by both parties in a marriage.

Denham CJ allowed the appeal and sent the case back to the High Court with the comment that the level of provision ordered by the High Court was excessive, particularly the order of €1million for the purchase of an additional house and the order for the sum of €600,000 for her use and benefit.

This case is a very important judgement dealing with a very important issue. Over the last number of years there have been many cases involving what has been commonly known as “the second bite of the cherry” cases. The court has handed down some very interesting guidance to anyone involved in such cases and will no doubt be the subject of much debate over the next number of months. It certainly appears that the Supreme Court is not in favour of what was the common practice over the last number of years of redistributing wealth, which was acquired after separation. It is also significant that the court considered that inherited assets were not to be treated as assets obtained by both parties in a marriage.


For further advice or if you wish to discuss any other legal area please contact [email protected] or telephone 052-6124344.

The material contained in this blog is provided for general information purposes only and does not amount to legal or other professional advice. While every care has been taken in the preparation of the information, we advise you to seek specific advice from us about any legal decision or course of action.

Tagged under: Proper Provision

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pages

  • Blog
  • Blog Categories
  • Contact Us
  • Divorce
  • Divorce Google Form Contact Form
  • Home
  • Our Fees
  • Our Team
    • Catherine McGrath
    • Emma Greene
    • Gabriele Plek
    • Gillian O’ Mahony
    • John M. Lynch
    • Roisín Kelly
    • Susanna Manton
  • Practice Areas
    • Arbitration
    • Mediation
    • Medical Negligence
    • Other Areas
    • Personal Injury and Accident
      • Accidents at Work
      • DePuy ASR Hip Implant Recall
      • Medical Negligence – A Quick Guide
      • Occupational Asthma
      • Repetitive Strain Injury
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • The Injuries Board – PIAB Process
      • Time Limits
    • Property Services
      • Co-ownership Agreements
      • Commercial Tenancies
      • Private Residential Tenancies
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Transfer of Assets
    • Separation, Divorce & Relationship Issues
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Maintenance
      • Marriage Breakdowns – Your Options
      • Prenuptial and Cohabitation Agreements
    • Wills,Succession & Estates
      • Bereavement Legal Issues
      • Enduring Power of Attorney – Preparing for the Future
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Spouses and Children: Know Your Inheritance Rights
      • Wills
  • Publications
  • Videos

WHAT ARE WE ABOUT

We strive to give a voice to you as an Individual. We offer client focused service and cutting edge process and technology through ongoing research. We represent the Individual as opposed to the large Organisation. We look after you in your dealings with the Establishment or, what might be called , the Institutional forces in society.

CONTACT US

+353 (52) 6124344

Office Address: Jervis House, Parnell Street, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary, Ireland.
Email: [email protected]

GOT A QUESTION - CONTACT US
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2017 | All rights reserved | Lynch Solicitors

TOP });