Lynch Solicitors - Personal Injuries & Equity Litigation, Medical Negligence, Bankruptcy,  Property and Estates  & Divorce and Family Law

Call Us: +353 52 6124344 | Email: [email protected]
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury & Litigation
      • DePuy Hip Implant
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • Accidents at Work
      • Acident on Roads & Footpaths
      • Mental Illness & Claims
      • Repetitive Strain Injuries
      • Pessonal Injuries Board
      • Time Limits to Claim
    • Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Medical Negligence
      • A Guide to Professional Negligence
      • Do I have a Case
      • Tips on Medical Negligence Cases
      • Medical Negligence – Narcolepsy
      • Time Limits to Claim
      • Solicitors in Medical Negligence
    • Divorce & Family Issues
      • Divorce
      • Breakdowns – the Options
      • How Assets are Dealt with
      • How Maintenance is assessed
      • Prenup & Co-habit Agreements
      • Mediation
      • Civil Partnerships
    • Property Services
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Rights Of Way Explained
      • How to own Property with another
      • Tips on Selling a Property
      • Tips on Business Leases
      • Tips on Renting
    • Wills, Succession & Estates
      • How a Will works
      • Why to make a Will
      • Executors, Guardians , Trustees & Attorneys
      • Enduring Powers of Attorney
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Bereavement - the Legal Process
      • Rights of Spouses and Children
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions
    • Our Fees
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookie Policy
CALL USSEND US YOUR QUERY
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Bankruptcy & Insolvency
  • Bank’s Claw Back of Mortgage Debt & The Insolvency Process
22/03/2023
John Lynch
Thursday, 05 September 2013 / Published in Bankruptcy & Insolvency

Bank’s Claw Back of Mortgage Debt & The Insolvency Process

Tipp FM Legal Slot – 3rd September 2013

 

John M. Lynch, Personal Solvency Practitioner on Banks Clawing Back Mortgage Debts & The Insolvency Process

[soundcloud id=’165869581′]

Download our Banks Claw Back of Mortgage Debt & The Insolvency Process notes Tipp FM

 

Last week we spoke to John Lynch who is now a Personal Insolvency Practitioner and was the first solicitor registered by the Insolvency Service of Ireland.  The ISI is due to begin accepting insolvency applications this Monday – 9th September, but there has been recent controversy surrounding the area.  John, is it the case that homeowners who enter into Personal Insolvency Arrangements (PIAs) may have to end up handing over some of the proceeds of the sale to the bank within 20 years?

There has been much negative speculation during the past few days about the Banks’ right under the legislation to claw back mortgages that have been written off for up to 20 years.  It was suggested that the banks had influenced the Insolvency Act and made an amendment to it to the effect that they could claw back any extra profits from the sale of assets up to 20 years.

This provision has been there from the outset; it’s not new.  Section 103 of the Personal Insolvency Act has set up a way to value the assets.  This is particularly important where an asset is in negative equity.

How is the market value of the asset determined?

Under the legislation there are three steps:

  • A PIP, a creditor and a debtor can agree a value;
  • If they can’t agree a value, they try to agree to appoint an independent expert;
  • If they can’t agree on an expert they refer the matter to the Insolvency Service of Ireland who appoints an expert and that expert determines the market value.

The market value needs to be established for the new arrangement.

In what situation may the banks be entitled to claw back the written off debt?

The claw back only comes into effect if someone makes a profit on the sale of their home.

If someone sells an asset as part of the insolvency arrangement the banks get  the sale proceeds or loan value.

If they cannot sell the asset a benchmark has to be decided on as to the realistically value of the asset.

If a value is put on an asset and it is not sold as part of the insolvency process, but at a later date when the borrower has returned to solvency it is sold, at a profit, then the banks would be entitled to claw back a portion of the proceeds for the amount that was written off.

The asset could be worth significantly more than the original market value at this stage.

This is a reasonable provision, particularly where the Act make provision for the owner taking the benefit of improvements.  The claw back only comes into effect if someone makes a profit, above the original market value, on the sale of their home when they are solvent.  It is not a charter for the Banks to make someone insolvent.

The primary objective of the Act is to let individuals stay in their homes and s. 103 does not change that.

Effectively, it has nothing to do with going from insolvency to solvency.

If the person holds on to the asset for more than 20 years – they can hold on to the profit.

The 20 years exists so that there is fairness on both sides – it’s not an unlimited open ended time frame – this very common in legal scenarios.

The new PIA, which will apply specifically to mortgage holders and those with secured and unsecured debts of €20,000 to €3 million, is NOT a charter for the Banks to keep someone insolvent.

If you have a mortgage that you can’t pay, you are on social welfare, and you have no disposable income, what can a person do?

I have come across this regularly as a PIP.

As a lawyer I am used to pro bono work.  There has to be some mechanism  for people who have no disposable income whatsoever.  When you are doing your arrangement you would make some provision; you would do a certain amount of work to get them in to a position of solvency and when they are in a position of solvency an arrangement can be made where a sustainable fee is spread over a period of time.

This legislation is grounded on social policy; the whole reason for social policy is that we are trying to put this country back up on its feet and everyone is entitled to benefit from it.

I am a advocate for this piece of legislation because if after five years enough people have gone through the process we will have a different country at the end of it.

Remind listeners again, when will you be submitting applications to the ISI?

The ISI is starting next Monday (9th September) and we have a number of target cases to submit to see how it will work.

As a Personal Insolvency Practitioner I will be acting independently and my function will be to bring people from insolvency back to solvency.  If I have a situation where the only way to do so is to force bankruptcy then as a lawyer and a PIP I will do this.

It is expected that up to 15,000 people may avail of the new deals under the Insolvency Service.


For further advice or if you wish to discuss any other legal area please contact [email protected] or telephone 052-6124344.

The material contained in this blog is provided for general information purposes only and does not amount to legal or other professional advice. While every care has been taken in the preparation of the information, we advise you to seek specific advice from us about any legal decision or course of action.

Tagged under: Mortgage Arrears, Personal Insolvency Arrangements

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pages

  • Blog
  • Blog Categories
  • Contact Us
  • Divorce
  • Divorce Google Form Contact Form
  • Home
  • Our Fees
  • Our Team
    • Catherine McGrath
    • Emma Greene
    • Gabriele Plek
    • Gillian O’ Mahony
    • John M. Lynch
    • Roisín Kelly
    • Susanna Manton
  • Practice Areas
    • Arbitration
    • Mediation
    • Medical Negligence
    • Other Areas
    • Personal Injury and Accident
      • Accidents at Work
      • DePuy ASR Hip Implant Recall
      • Medical Negligence – A Quick Guide
      • Occupational Asthma
      • Repetitive Strain Injury
      • Road Traffic Accidents
      • The Injuries Board – PIAB Process
      • Time Limits
    • Property Services
      • Co-ownership Agreements
      • Commercial Tenancies
      • Private Residential Tenancies
      • Tips for First Time Buyers
      • Transfer of Assets
    • Separation, Divorce & Relationship Issues
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Maintenance
      • Marriage Breakdowns – Your Options
      • Prenuptial and Cohabitation Agreements
    • Wills,Succession & Estates
      • Bereavement Legal Issues
      • Enduring Power of Attorney – Preparing for the Future
      • Fair Deal Scheme
      • Spouses and Children: Know Your Inheritance Rights
      • Wills
  • Publications
  • Videos

WHAT ARE WE ABOUT

We strive to give a voice to you as an Individual. We offer client focused service and cutting edge process and technology through ongoing research. We represent the Individual as opposed to the large Organisation. We look after you in your dealings with the Establishment or, what might be called , the Institutional forces in society.

CONTACT US

+353 (52) 6124344

Office Address: Jervis House, Parnell Street, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary, Ireland.
Email: [email protected]

GOT A QUESTION - CONTACT US
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • News & Blogs
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2017 | All rights reserved | Lynch Solicitors

TOP });